sand•wich (noun)- an item of food consisting of two pieces of bread with meat cheese or other filling between them, eaten as a light meal.
That’s how the dictionary defines a sandwich. Because the definition is so broad, I can’t disagree with it. However, my personal interpretation of “sandwich” is a little more specific.
I think that for something to be called a sandwich, it should consist of two slices of bread that hold an ingredient or two (or seven) between them. Now, let’s break it down. Since we’re already overthinking “what is a sandwich?” shouldn’t we also analyze the question, “what is bread?”
To me, bread has to be something that comes in loaves. According to my thought process, the debate of whether or not hamburgers, quesadillas, or crepes are sandwiches is over. Buns, tortillas and thin pancakes don’t come in a the form of a chunk of carbs that can be sliced, therefore, they should not be considered a sandwich. Who looks at a crepe and correlates it with “sandwich”, anyway?
Now that I have my definition of bread, I am now confronted with narrowing down what kinds of breads are specifically sandwich breads. From personal experience, there seems to be a fixed group of breads that fall into the acceptable category of sandwich bread. White, wheat, rye, whole grain, texas toast and sourdough or any other variation of those (honey what, 12 grain, etc) all pass for valid bread types. They are the typical choices when asked what kinds of toast are offered at a diner, or what is displayed at the grocery store. They’re also the kinds of breads that people eat common sandwiches on. The ham sandwich, turkey sandwich, peanut butter and jelly sandwich, BLT, fluffernutter, etc, are normally on one of these basic kinds of breads.
The only cloudy area of my definition of “sandwich” is that I mostly think that a sandwich has to have the word “sandwich” in its title, however, there are exceptions. The ham sandwich and turkey sandwich, and even the peanut butter and jelly sandwich are staple lunch sandwiches that use the type of food it is in its name. The BLT, panini, and rueben typically aren’t referred to as “a BLT sandwich” or the like. I argue that these concoctions are indeed sandwiches, but an exception to my rules.
A sandwich’s broad element lies in between the bread. I feel that anything that is eatable and can fit in between two slices, is acceptable. Whether its sweet jam or salty bacon, anything goes when it comes to sandwiches. White meat, dark meat, cheese, spreads, fruits, veggies, dressings, jellies, hummus, you name it; it has probably been on a sandwich. No matter how you define a sandwich, we all agree that the word is up for interpretation. That’s what makes a sandwich so appealing anyway, right? Their flexibility and versatility. So pick up a BLT or whip yourself up a quick PBJ, and get your sandwich on.